2010 Nov 2 :: State of Michigan :: State ProposalSTATE PROPOSAL 10-1: A PROPOSAL TO CONVENE A CONSTITUTIONAL CONVENTION FOR THE PURPOSE OF DRAFTING A GENERAL REVISION OF THE STATE CONSTITUTION See summary »
SHARE THIS DATA:
Actions
Shall a convention of elected delegates be convened in 2011 to draft a general revision of the State Constitution for presentation to the state's voters for their approval or rejection?
Constitutional Convention
If the electors in November vote in favor of calling a convention, within six months after the proposal is certified as approved, a partisan election must be held to choose a delegate from each senatorial district and each representative district (148 total); and the delegates will have to convene in Lansing on the first Tuesday in October 2011, or earlier if provided by law.
The convention may change the existing Constitution in any way it sees fit; it could completely revise the document, submit specific amendments, or do nothing. The convention also may alter or delete any ballot proposal to amend the Constitution that the voters approve in the November 2010 election.
Any proposed constitution or amendments adopted by the convention must be submitted to the voters in a manner and at a time provided by the convention, but at least 90 days after final adjournment of the convention. If approved, the constitution or amendments will take effect as provided by the convention.
If voters on November 2, 2010, reject the calling of a convention, the question will appear on the ballot again in 2026.
Fiscal Impact
If the voters were to approve Proposal 10-1, the combined costs of holding a convention, and related election expenses, could exceed $45.0 million. Costs for holding the 1961-62 convention, which lasted seven and one-half months, totaled $2.0 million ($1,080,000 for delegate salaries; $920,000 for rent, printing, employees, etc.). Based on the level of inflation from 1962 through 2008 (685.7%), the cost of holding a convention today would be approximately $13.7 million. In addition, the process could involve three statewide elections: one for a primary to select delegates to the convention; one for a general election to elect delegates; and an election to ratify any document the convention produced. (For the current Constitution, primary and general elections were held to select delegates in 1961 and a ratification election was held in 1963.) According to the Bureau of Elections at the Department of State, a statewide election costs approximately $2,000 per voting precinct and there are 5,200 precincts in Michigan. The estimated cost per election is $10.4 million. Thus, if the process required three elections (that is, if none were held concurrently with other scheduled elections), election expenditures could exceed $31.2 million.
Background
The constitutional convention requirement has a long history in Michigan, having first appeared in the 1850 Constitution. The 1850 document remained in effect until a convention was called in 1907, resulting in adoption of the 1908 Constitution. Ballot proposals to call a constitutional convention failed in 1926, 1942, 1948, and 1958, even though the latter two elections resulted in more "yes" votes than "no" votes. Though the 1948 and 1958 ballot questions showed that a majority of those voting on the question favored a new convention, a convention was not called because the 1908 Constitution contained a requirement that, to call a convention, a majority of those voting at the election vote "yes". (That is, many people who voted at the election apparently did not vote on the convention question.)
In 1960, a citizen initiative placed on the ballot a proposed constitutional amendment to require a convention if a majority of those voting on the question voted in favor. The amendment was passed in November 1960 and, as required in the amendment, the question of calling a convention was placed before the voters the following April. The question was approved and a constitutional convention was convened on October 3, 1961. That convention produced Michigan's present Constitution, which was approved by the voters on April 1, 1963. Voters defeated the constitutional convention question on the 1978 and 1994 ballots.
2010 Nov 2 :: State of Michigan :: State ProposalSTATE PROPOSAL 10-1: A PROPOSAL TO CONVENE A CONSTITUTIONAL CONVENTION FOR THE PURPOSE OF DRAFTING A GENERAL REVISION OF THE STATE CONSTITUTION See summary »
Ballot Question Results
Precinct |
|
|
Total Votes Cast |
---|---|---|---|
Totals |
36,456 |
71,954 |
108,410 |
Ann Arbor City, AVCB 1 1A |
45 |
78 |
123 |
Ann Arbor City, AVCB 2 1B |
22 |
50 |
72 |
Ann Arbor City, AVCB 3 1C |
30 |
46 |
76 |
Ann Arbor City, AVCB 4 1D |
152 |
259 |
411 |
Ann Arbor City, AVCB 5 1E |
10 |
11 |
21 |
Ann Arbor City, AVCB 6 2A |
376 |
688 |
1,064 |
Ann Arbor City, AVCB 7 2B |
36 |
74 |
110 |
Ann Arbor City, AVCB 8 2C |
97 |
137 |
234 |
Ann Arbor City, AVCB 9 2D |
74 |
162 |
236 |
Ann Arbor City, AVCB 10 3A |
130 |
190 |
320 |
Ann Arbor City, AVCB 11 3B |
1 |
0 |
1 |
Ann Arbor City, AVCB 12 3C |
239 |
615 |
854 |
Ann Arbor City, AVCB 13 4A |
467 |
885 |
1,352 |
Ann Arbor City, AVCB 14 4B |
7 |
2 |
9 |
Ann Arbor City, AVCB 15 4C |
8 |
7 |
15 |
Ann Arbor City, AVCB 16 5A |
16 |
33 |
49 |
Ann Arbor City, AVCB 17 5B |
0 |
1 |
1 |
Ann Arbor City, AVCB 18 5C |
487 |
1,016 |
1,503 |
Ann Arbor City, AVCB 19 5D |
2 |
4 |
6 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 1, Precinct 1 |
161 |
89 |
250 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 1, Precinct 2 |
95 |
66 |
161 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 1, Precinct 3 |
113 |
93 |
206 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 1, Precinct 4 |
220 |
299 |
519 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 1, Precinct 5 |
186 |
349 |
535 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 1, Precinct 6 |
142 |
196 |
338 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 1, Precinct 7 |
219 |
114 |
333 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 1, Precinct 8 |
236 |
450 |
686 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 1, Precinct 9 |
298 |
482 |
780 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 1, Precinct 10 |
249 |
472 |
721 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 2, Precinct 1 |
127 |
181 |
308 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 2, Precinct 2 |
196 |
101 |
297 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 2, Precinct 3 |
103 |
125 |
228 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 2, Precinct 4 |
195 |
431 |
626 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 2, Precinct 5 |
241 |
455 |
696 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 2, Precinct 6 |
255 |
474 |
729 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 2, Precinct 7 |
241 |
463 |
704 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 2, Precinct 8 |
176 |
367 |
543 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 2, Precinct 9 |
289 |
501 |
790 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 3, Precinct 1 |
166 |
93 |
259 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 3, Precinct 2 |
121 |
119 |
240 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 3, Precinct 3 |
302 |
647 |
949 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 3, Precinct 4 |
203 |
444 |
647 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 3, Precinct 5 |
238 |
359 |
597 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 3, Precinct 6 |
252 |
353 |
605 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 3, Precinct 7 |
214 |
494 |
708 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 3, Precinct 8 |
268 |
505 |
773 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 3, Precinct 9 |
224 |
428 |
652 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 4, Precinct 1 |
148 |
94 |
242 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 4, Precinct 2 |
71 |
64 |
135 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 4, Precinct 3 |
192 |
263 |
455 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 4, Precinct 4 |
251 |
510 |
761 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 4, Precinct 5 |
174 |
367 |
541 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 4, Precinct 6 |
268 |
551 |
819 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 4, Precinct 7 |
285 |
546 |
831 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 4, Precinct 8 |
194 |
273 |
467 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 4, Precinct 9 |
288 |
630 |
918 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 5, Precinct 1 |
123 |
110 |
233 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 5, Precinct 2 |
284 |
522 |
806 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 5, Precinct 3 |
167 |
257 |
424 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 5, Precinct 4 |
289 |
607 |
896 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 5, Precinct 5 |
231 |
404 |
635 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 5, Precinct 6 |
201 |
437 |
638 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 5, Precinct 7 |
145 |
200 |
345 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 5, Precinct 8 |
140 |
331 |
471 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 5, Precinct 9 |
290 |
521 |
811 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 5, Precinct 10 |
222 |
562 |
784 |
Ann Arbor City, Ward 5, Precinct 11 |
329 |
723 |
1,052 |
Ann Arbor Township, Precinct 1 |
249 |
672 |
921 |
Ann Arbor Township, Precinct 2 |
284 |
565 |
849 |
Augusta Township, Precinct 1 |
251 |
537 |
788 |
Augusta Township, Precinct 2 |
164 |
382 |
546 |
Augusta Township, Precinct 3 |
254 |
626 |
880 |
Bridgewater Township, Precinct 1 |
146 |
533 |
679 |
Chelsea City, AVCB 1 |
214 |
393 |
607 |
Chelsea City, Precinct 1 |
326 |
565 |
891 |
Chelsea City, Precinct 2 |
177 |
324 |
501 |
Dexter Township, AVCB 1 |
169 |
418 |
587 |
Dexter Township, Precinct 1 |
243 |
528 |
771 |
Dexter Township, Precinct 2 |
233 |
520 |
753 |
Dexter Township, Precinct 3 |
127 |
304 |
431 |
Freedom Township, Precinct 1 |
152 |
502 |
654 |
Lima Township, Precinct 1 |
370 |
958 |
1,328 |
Lodi Township, AVCB 1 |
202 |
513 |
715 |
Lodi Township, Precinct 1 |
319 |
811 |
1,130 |
Lodi Township, Precinct 2 |
235 |
545 |
780 |
Lyndon Township, AVCB 1 |
85 |
249 |
334 |
Lyndon Township, Precinct 1 |
227 |
507 |
734 |
Manchester Township, Precinct 1 |
265 |
504 |
769 |
Manchester Township, Precinct 2 |
264 |
739 |
1,003 |
Milan City, AVCB 1W |
68 |
142 |
210 |
Milan City, Precinct 1W |
323 |
665 |
988 |
Northfield Township, AVCB 1 |
234 |
484 |
718 |
Northfield Township, Precinct 1 |
286 |
591 |
877 |
Northfield Township, Precinct 2 |
183 |
535 |
718 |
Northfield Township, Precinct 3 |
165 |
383 |
548 |
Pittsfield Charter Township, AVCB 1 |
615 |
1,263 |
1,878 |
Pittsfield Charter Township, Precinct 1 |
341 |
728 |
1,069 |
Pittsfield Charter Township, Precinct 2 |
253 |
422 |
675 |
Pittsfield Charter Township, Precinct 3 |
279 |
502 |
781 |
Pittsfield Charter Township, Precinct 4 |
162 |
168 |
330 |
Pittsfield Charter Township, Precinct 5 |
115 |
190 |
305 |
Pittsfield Charter Township, Precinct 6 |
277 |
502 |
779 |
Pittsfield Charter Township, Precinct 7 |
315 |
612 |
927 |
Pittsfield Charter Township, Precinct 8 |
341 |
737 |
1,078 |
Pittsfield Charter Township, Precinct 9 |
332 |
675 |
1,007 |
Pittsfield Charter Township, Precinct 10 |
141 |
204 |
345 |
Pittsfield Charter Township, Precinct 11 |
140 |
175 |
315 |
Salem Township, AVCB 1 |
193 |
477 |
670 |
Salem Township, Precinct 1 |
162 |
487 |
649 |
Salem Township, Precinct 2 |
169 |
456 |
625 |
Salem Township, Precinct 3 |
138 |
327 |
465 |
Saline City, AVCB 1 |
268 |
569 |
837 |
Saline City, Precinct 1 |
264 |
590 |
854 |
Saline City, Precinct 2 |
226 |
437 |
663 |
Saline City, Precinct 3 |
347 |
643 |
990 |
Saline Township, Precinct 1 |
180 |
481 |
661 |
Scio Township, Precinct 1 |
409 |
781 |
1,190 |
Scio Township, Precinct 2 |
141 |
445 |
586 |
Scio Township, Precinct 3 |
249 |
539 |
788 |
Scio Township, Precinct 4 |
257 |
531 |
788 |
Scio Township, Precinct 5 |
232 |
384 |
616 |
Scio Township, Precinct 6 |
249 |
417 |
666 |
Scio Township, Precinct 7 |
379 |
694 |
1,073 |
Scio Township, Precinct 8 |
326 |
824 |
1,150 |
Scio Township, Precinct 9 |
272 |
504 |
776 |
Sharon Township, Precinct 1 |
202 |
576 |
778 |
Superior Township, AVCB 1 |
399 |
647 |
1,046 |
Superior Township, Precinct 1 |
212 |
415 |
627 |
Superior Township, Precinct 2 |
278 |
554 |
832 |
Superior Township, Precinct 3 |
190 |
274 |
464 |
Superior Township, Precinct 4 |
193 |
332 |
525 |
Superior Township, Precinct 5 |
222 |
578 |
800 |
Sylvan Township, Precinct 1 |
399 |
924 |
1,323 |
Webster Township, Precinct 1 |
327 |
869 |
1,196 |
Webster Township, Precinct 2 |
218 |
592 |
810 |
Webster Township, Precinct 3 |
253 |
601 |
854 |
York Township, AVCB 1 |
216 |
580 |
796 |
York Township, Precinct 1 |
175 |
519 |
694 |
York Township, Precinct 2 |
230 |
542 |
772 |
York Township, Precinct 3 |
164 |
423 |
587 |
Ypsilanti City, AVCB 1 |
286 |
545 |
831 |
Ypsilanti City, Ward 1, Precinct 1 |
134 |
152 |
286 |
Ypsilanti City, Ward 1, Precinct 2 |
153 |
226 |
379 |
Ypsilanti City, Ward 1, Precinct 3 |
110 |
145 |
255 |
Ypsilanti City, Ward 2, Precinct 1 |
106 |
287 |
393 |
Ypsilanti City, Ward 2, Precinct 2 |
144 |
278 |
422 |
Ypsilanti City, Ward 2, Precinct 3 |
144 |
287 |
431 |
Ypsilanti City, Ward 2, Precinct 4 |
78 |
61 |
139 |
Ypsilanti City, Ward 3, Precinct 1 |
72 |
65 |
137 |
Ypsilanti City, Ward 3, Precinct 2 |
152 |
285 |
437 |
Ypsilanti City, Ward 3, Precinct 3 |
222 |
313 |
535 |
Ypsilanti Township, AVCB 1 |
529 |
1,089 |
1,618 |
Ypsilanti Township, AVCB 2 |
613 |
1,051 |
1,664 |
Ypsilanti Township, Precinct 1 |
223 |
319 |
542 |
Ypsilanti Township, Precinct 2 |
186 |
380 |
566 |
Ypsilanti Township, Precinct 3 |
155 |
242 |
397 |
Ypsilanti Township, Precinct 4 |
242 |
463 |
705 |
Ypsilanti Township, Precinct 5 |
142 |
221 |
363 |
Ypsilanti Township, Precinct 6 |
87 |
126 |
213 |
Ypsilanti Township, Precinct 7 |
150 |
261 |
411 |
Ypsilanti Township, Precinct 8 |
156 |
287 |
443 |
Ypsilanti Township, Precinct 9 |
197 |
505 |
702 |
Ypsilanti Township, Precinct 10 |
150 |
239 |
389 |
Ypsilanti Township, Precinct 11 |
188 |
329 |
517 |
Ypsilanti Township, Precinct 12 |
218 |
288 |
506 |
Ypsilanti Township, Precinct 13 |
211 |
358 |
569 |
Ypsilanti Township, Precinct 14 |
205 |
528 |
733 |
Ypsilanti Township, Precinct 15 |
86 |
201 |
287 |
Ypsilanti Township Precinct 16 |
68 |
178 |
246 |
Ypsilanti Township, Precinct 17 |
432 |
764 |
1,196 |
Ypsilanti Township, Precinct 18 |
207 |
437 |
644 |
Ypsilanti Township, Precinct 19 |
284 |
491 |
775 |
Ypsilanti Township, Precinct 20 |
240 |
488 |
728 |
Totals |
36,456 |
71,954 |
108,410 |